The short answer: freezing is optional, not required
A common baby teether myth is that every teether must go in the freezer to work. The supplied product information does not support that blanket rule. Chilling can be one way to offer cold teething relief, but it depends on the teether's materials and care instructions.
The Fargo Freezer Teether is explicitly described as a freezer toy that can be chilled, not frozen. The Duke Star Teether is a mix of silicone and beeswax-treated beechwood, and its care instructions say to clean with a wipe and not to soak it in water. That difference matters when you decide how to use each one.
Fargo vs. Duke: chilling and cleaning at a glance
- Fargo Freezer Teether: 100% food-grade silicone ring; can be chilled, not frozen; clean with soapy water; approximately 2.75 x 2.75 in.
- Duke Star Teether: Silicone and beeswax-treated beechwood; clean with a wipe; do not soak in water; approximately 4 x 4 in.; treat wood with beeswax or coconut oil.
What the Fargo freezer teether actually allows
- Freezer Teether - Fargo: Can be chilled, not freezed (as written in the catalog). This is the clearest evidence that freezing is not the intended use for this teether, even though it is marketed as a freezer teether.

Freezer Teether - Fargo - Freezer Teether - Fargo: Easily to clean with soapy water. Silicone can be washed, which suits a teether that may go into the fridge and then into a baby's mouth.
- Freezer Teether - Fargo: Approximately 2.75 x 2.75 in. A smaller ring is easy for small hands to grab and hold, according to the catalog description.
How to chill a baby teether safely
If you want to offer a cold teether for sore gums, follow the manufacturer's chilling instructions for that specific product. For the Fargo Freezer Teether, the catalog says it can be chilled, not frozen. That means placing it in the refrigerator rather than the freezer. The catalog does not specify a chilling time, so use your judgment and check the teether before giving it to your baby.
For the Duke Star Teether, the supplied information does not mention chilling at all. Its materials include beeswax-treated beechwood, and the care instructions say to clean with a wipe and not to soak in water. Because the catalog does not confirm that the Duke can be chilled or frozen, do not assume it is freezer-safe. If you want a cold option, the Fargo is the teether with explicit chilling guidance.
What the Duke star teether does and does not say about cold
- Star Teether - Duke: A mix of soft silicone and beechwood that have been treated with beeswax. Wood and silicone have different care needs, and the catalog does not list chilling as a use for this teether.

Star Teether - Duke - Star Teether - Duke: Clean with wipe. Do not soak in water. This is a cleaning rule, not a chilling rule, but it shows the Duke is not designed for the same kind of washing as an all-silicone teether.
- Star Teether - Duke: We recommend treating wood with beeswax or coconut oil for smoothness and longer-lasting. This maintenance step is specific to the wooden part and is separate from any chilling question.
Baby teether myths worth retiring
- Myth: Every teether must be frozen to soothe gums.: The Fargo can be chilled, not frozen, and the Duke has no chilling instruction in the supplied information. Cold can be optional, not mandatory.
- Myth: If a teether is called a freezer teether, you can freeze it solid.: The Fargo catalog explicitly says 'can be chilled, not freezed.' Follow that wording rather than the product name alone.
- Myth: All teethers can be washed the same way.: The Fargo can be cleaned with soapy water; the Duke should be cleaned with a wipe and not soaked in water.
What the catalog does not settle
The supplied information does not give a chilling time for the Fargo, nor does it state whether the Duke can be chilled. It also does not specify an age range for either teether. The catalog notes that both contain small parts and should be used with supervision, inspected before each use, and discarded at the first sign of damage. Those safety steps apply whether or not you chill the teether.
When in doubt, choose the teether whose instructions match what you plan to do. If you want a cold option, the Fargo is the one with clear chilling guidance. If you prefer a wood-and-silicone teether, the Duke is designed for wiping rather than soaking or freezing.


